カテゴリー: 無住心言術道場

  • 無住心言術道場第0112回

    Logos Dojo No. 112

    Generational Differences in Perceptions of Nuclear Deterrence in the Russia–Ukraine War

    A Preliminary Inquiry from the Perspective of Structuralist Sociology

    This essay considers the possibility that the concept of “nuclear deterrence,” which has remained part of international security discourse since the Cold War, may carry different meanings across generations and societies. The discussion is intended to remain as politically neutral as reasonably possible.

    Since the end of the Cold War, calls for nuclear disarmament and the abolition of nuclear weapons have been advanced by many countries and civil-society organizations, including those in Japan, the only country to have experienced atomic bombings in war. The recognition that nuclear weapons are capable of causing catastrophic harm to humanity can reasonably be regarded as widely shared across national boundaries.

    At the same time, nuclear weapons continue to exist as a material component of contemporary international security. The concept of nuclear deterrence has likewise not disappeared from the security policies of nuclear-armed states.

    This raises an important question for the study of contemporary international relations.

    When international conflicts are discussed primarily in terms of victory or defeat through conventional warfare, there is a possibility that the risks associated with nuclear deterrence and nuclear escalation may receive comparatively insufficient attention.

    This does not mean that a strategic defeat involving conventional forces would necessarily lead to the use of nuclear weapons. Nuclear doctrines, policies, and decision-making frameworks differ among nuclear-armed states.

    Nevertheless, it would also be inappropriate to assume that conventional warfare and nuclear deterrence can always be treated as entirely separate domains.

    The Russia–Ukraine war has involved the large-scale use of drones and other relatively new military technologies, contributing to changes in the conduct of warfare.

    However, this essay will not examine specific strategies or tactics that might directly affect military operations. Such matters fall outside the scope and purpose of this discussion.

    The principal concern here is not military technology itself, but rather how people understand the concept of “nuclear deterrence.”

    It is possible that generations that directly experienced the Cold War and generations that grew up after its conclusion may associate different meanings with nuclear weapons and nuclear deterrence.

    This possibility should not be understood as a phenomenon specific to either Russia or Ukraine.

    Within Russia, Ukraine, Europe, the United States, Japan, and other societies, perceptions of nuclear weapons may vary according to generation, education, profession, military experience, historical understanding, and other social and individual factors.

    At this point, a structuralist perspective may provide a useful analytical framework.

    Structuralism allows us to examine a linguistic or semantic system synchronically—that is, as a structure operating at a particular point in time—while also examining diachronically how that system and its meanings have changed over historical time.

    This distinction can be provisionally applied to the concept of nuclear deterrence.

    Even when the expression “nuclear deterrence”—the signifier (signifiant), or the perceptible form of the sign—remains the same, the signified (signifié), or the conceptual content associated with it, need not necessarily be identical across societies or generations.

    For example, for people who directly experienced the Cold War, the expression “nuclear deterrence” may be strongly associated with the confrontation between the United States and the Soviet Union, the nuclear arms race, the Cuban Missile Crisis, mutually assured destruction, and the fear of general nuclear war.

    For generations that grew up after the end of the Cold War, by contrast, nuclear weapons may still be understood as an immense threat while simultaneously being perceived as weapons that have not been used in warfare for a long period of time.

    The purpose of this comparison is not to determine which generation possesses the “correct” perception.

    Rather, the analytical question is whether different social groups may construct different signifieds in relation to the same signifier, “nuclear deterrence.”

    If such asymmetries of meaning exist between states or among social groups, they could potentially contribute to misunderstanding, misperception, or miscalculation in international politics.

    This possibility may also be relevant when considering the future course of the Russia–Ukraine war.

    Rather than conceptualizing the conflict exclusively in terms of two outcomes—“a Russian victory” or “a Ukrainian victory”—it is also necessary to consider a third analytical concern: the avoidance of catastrophic escalation in a conflict involving a nuclear-armed state.

    From this perspective, I believe that the possibility of a ceasefire or negotiated settlement that does not constitute a complete victory for either side—a form of “bittersweet” peace—should not be excluded from consideration.

    This statement should not be interpreted as a proposal for any particular territorial settlement or as an endorsement of specific terms for a peace agreement.

    The specific conditions of any ceasefire or peace settlement are matters to be addressed through diplomacy and through the relevant frameworks of international law and international security by the parties directly concerned and other relevant states.

    The argument presented here is considerably narrower.

    In addition to examining victory and defeat in conventional warfare, we may also need to examine the meanings that different states, societies, and generations attribute to the sign of “nuclear deterrence.”

    From the perspective of structuralist sociology:

    The sharing of the same signifier does not necessarily imply the sharing of the same signified.

    Understanding such differences in meaning may provide one analytical perspective from which to consider how misperception and miscalculation concerning nuclear weapons might be reduced, and how catastrophic outcomes might be avoided.

    Because this essay addresses an exceptionally sensitive subject, I will not discuss specific military strategies or tactics. I will therefore conclude at the level of this limited analytical proposition.

    I will leave the discussion here for today. (with AI)

    This article is in the public domain under CC0.

  • 無住心言術道場道場第0111回

    Logos Dojo, No. 111

    “A Proposal for Social Scientists to Contribute as Technical and Academic Specialists to Building Better States and Societies Together with Policymakers and Citizens”

    The world is currently facing a growing number of destabilizing factors.

    Under these conditions, if humanity is to avoid destructive conflict and build a better future, greater use should be made of social-scientific methods for analyzing, designing, and evaluating institutions and social systems.

    I would therefore like to define this idea more clearly.

    Governments and citizens around the world have developed various policies and institutions in pursuit of better states and societies. These efforts, however, have not always produced the intended results.

    Responsibility for examining these limitations lies not only with policymakers. Researchers in the social sciences, including myself, should continually reconsider and improve their methods of analysis, prediction, institutional design, and evaluation.

    My proposal can be summarized in three points.

    1. National and Social Objectives

    Policymakers and citizens should seek to develop a shared and sufficiently clear vision of the kind of state and society they wish to build.

    2. The Role of Social Scientists

    To contribute to the realization of these objectives, social scientists should provide professional expertise not only in social analysis, but also in institutional design, policy evaluation, and the assessment of possible future outcomes.

    3. Social-System Design Based on Social Science

    To help realize social objectives shared by policymakers and citizens, social-scientific knowledge can be used to design institutional and policy options and to evaluate their expected effects, risks, and unintended consequences.

    In a narrow sense, such design concerns institutions and public policy. In a broader sense, however, it may also involve areas in which the social sciences and humanities overlap, including social norms, values, education, culture, and community.

    Social scientists, however, should not unilaterally determine the values or objectives of society. Their role is not to decide social goals on behalf of policymakers or citizens. Rather, their task is to examine the feasibility, institutional alternatives, expected effects, risks, and unintended consequences associated with goals developed through democratic and public deliberation.

    The contemporary world contains many sources of instability.

    To contribute to a better future, social scientists should therefore serve not only as analysts of society, but also as specialists capable of helping to design and evaluate institutions and public policies in support of the states and societies that policymakers and citizens seek to build.

    Licensing and AI Assistance Notice

    As with previous installments, I have received assistance from ChatGPT Plus in editing my original writing and providing suggestions for improvement.

    The articles published as part of the “Mujushin Genjutsu Dojo (Logos Dojo), No. XXX” series are made available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).

    Author: Tadamichi Hariya
    AI Assistance: Copilot and ChatGPT were used to assist with drafting, editing, proofreading, and refinement.
    Source: The original text published on this website.
    License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)

    Under the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license, you may copy, redistribute, translate, adapt, modify, and make commercial use of this material, provided that appropriate attribution is given to the author.

    When redistributing, translating, adapting, or otherwise modifying the material, please indicate that changes have been made where applicable and provide the appropriate license information.

    Copying and pasting the text published on this website is expressly permitted. You are also welcome to use generative AI systems to translate the material into other languages and to save, reproduce, or redistribute such translations in those languages, subject to the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license.

    The material may also be incorporated into software. In such cases, attribution may be included in the source code or accompanying documentation. A simple attribution such as:

    “Tadamichi Hariya — CC BY 4.0”

    may be used, together with appropriate license information or a link to the CC BY 4.0 license where reasonably practicable. If the material has been modified, translated, or adapted, this should also be indicated as required by the license.

    This notice is intended as a plain-language summary of the permitted uses of the material. In the event of any inconsistency, the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License govern. Creative Commons — CC BY 4.0 official license page

    無住心言術道場(Logos Dojo)第111回

    「世界の多くの国々の政策担当者と市民がともに目指す、より良い国家と社会の形成に、社会科学者が技術的・学術的に貢献するための提言」

    現在、世界では多くの不安定要因が顕在化しています。

    このような状況の中で、人類が深刻な対立や破壊を回避し、より良い未来を築くためには、国家や社会の制度を分析し、設計し、評価するための社会科学的な技術が、これまで以上に重要になると考えます。

    ここで、この考え方を明確に定義したいと思います。

    これまで世界各国では、政策担当者や市民が、より良い国家と社会を実現するために、さまざまな政策や制度を構築してきました。しかし、それらが常に十分な成果をもたらしたとは限りません。

    この点については、政策を立案する側だけではなく、私自身を含めた社会科学に携わる研究者も、分析、予測、制度設計および評価のあり方を継続的に検証する必要があります。

    今回の提言は、次の三点に整理できます。

    1.国家的・社会的目標

    世界各国において、政策担当者と市民が、より良い国家と社会について共有可能なビジョンを形成することです。

    2.社会科学者の役割

    その目標を実現するため、社会科学者は、社会の分析だけでなく、制度設計、政策評価、将来予測などを通じて、専門的な立場から貢献することが求められます。

    3.社会科学による社会システムの設計

    政策担当者と市民が共有する社会的目標を実現するために、社会科学の知見を用いて、制度や政策の選択肢を設計し、その効果と副作用を検証することが必要です。

    ここでいう「設計」は、狭義には制度設計を意味します。しかし、広義には、社会的規範、価値観、教育、文化、共同体など、人文科学と社会科学が重なり合う領域も含みます。

    ただし、社会科学者が社会の価値観そのものを一方的に決定するべきではありません。社会科学者の役割は、政策担当者や市民に代わって社会の目的を決定することではなく、民主的・公共的な議論によって形成された目標について、その実現可能性、制度的選択肢、期待される効果、リスクおよび副作用を分析することにあります。

    現在の世界には、多くの不安定要因があります。

    この世界をより良い方向へ進めるために、社会科学者は、政策担当者と市民が求める国家と社会の形成に向けて、分析者であると同時に、制度と政策を設計・評価する専門家として貢献することが、今の時代には必要であると考えます。

    今回もChat GPT Plusさんから私の拙い文章の校正と提案を受けています。

    この「無住心言術道場 第○○○回」の文章は、Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International(CC BY 4.0)で公開します。
    著作者:針屋忠道
    AI利用:Copilot および ChatGPT を草案作成・推敲補助に使用
    出典:本ホームページ掲載原文
    ライセンス:CC BY 4.0

    このライセンスのもとで、著作者表示を行う限り、複製、転載、翻訳、改変、商用利用を含む再利用が可能です。再利用の際は、必要に応じて改変の有無を明記してください。
    本ホームページ掲載文のコピー・アンド・ペースト、および生成AIを用いた各国語への翻訳・各国語での保存も許可します。ソフトウェアに組み込む場合は、ソースコードに簡単にTadamichi Hariyaと書けば問題ありません。

    今回も、生成AIの思考能力の高さを実感しました。

  • 無住心言術道場第0110回

    Logos Dojo, No. 110

    “A Mathematical Explanation of Information-Processing Economics: Definite Integrals of Three Curves—the S&P 500 Rate-of-Change Curve, the Price Rate-of-Change Curve, and the Wage Rate-of-Change Curve”


    This section restates the mathematical description of the three curves introduced in No. 105.

    A. Definite Integrals of the Three Rate-of-Change Curves

    1. S&P 500 Rate-of-Change Curve

    \(
    I_S = \int_a^b S(t) dt
    \)

    Here, (S(t)) represents the rate of change of the S&P 500 at time (t).

    2. Price Rate-of-Change Curve

    \(
    I_P = \int_a^b P(t) dt
    \)

    Here, (P(t)) represents the rate of change in prices at time (t).

    3. Wage Rate-of-Change Curve

    \(
    I_W= \int_a^b W(t) dt
    \)

    \( x1(t)=s \) \( (t),x2(t)=p \) \( (t),x3(t)=w \)


    B. A Mathematically General Description of the Differences among the Three Curves

    \( D_{ij}=\int_a^b \bigl(x_i(t)-x_j(t)\bigr)\,dt \quad (i,j\in\{1,2,3\},\ i\ne j) \)


    \( D_{ji}=-D_{ij} \)

    There are six ordered pairwise differences, but only three independent differences.


    C. An Economic Description of the Differences among the Three Curves

    \( D_1=D_{12}=\int_a^b \bigl(S(t)-P(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_2=D_{21}=\int_a^b \bigl(P(t)-S(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_3= D_{13}=\int_a^b \bigl(S(t)-W(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_4=D_{31}=\int_a^b \bigl(W(t)-S(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_5=D_{32}=\int_a^b \bigl(W(t)-P(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_6=D_{23}=\int_a^b \bigl(P(t)-W(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_1,\ldots,D_6 \)

    In economic terms, this area should be understood not as an economic entity itself, but as an approximate indicator of the cumulative difference in rates of change.

    Licensing and AI Assistance Notice

    As with previous installments, I have received assistance from ChatGPT Plus in editing my original writing and providing suggestions for improvement.

    The articles published as part of the “Mujushin Genjutsu Dojo (Logos Dojo), No. XXX” series are made available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).

    Author: Tadamichi Hariya
    AI Assistance: Copilot and ChatGPT were used to assist with drafting, editing, proofreading, and refinement.
    Source: The original text published on this website.
    License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)

    Under the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license, you may copy, redistribute, translate, adapt, modify, and make commercial use of this material, provided that appropriate attribution is given to the author.

    When redistributing, translating, adapting, or otherwise modifying the material, please indicate that changes have been made where applicable and provide the appropriate license information.

    Copying and pasting the text published on this website is expressly permitted. You are also welcome to use generative AI systems to translate the material into other languages and to save, reproduce, or redistribute such translations in those languages, subject to the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license.

    The material may also be incorporated into software. In such cases, attribution may be included in the source code or accompanying documentation. A simple attribution such as:

    “Tadamichi Hariya — CC BY 4.0”

    may be used, together with appropriate license information or a link to the CC BY 4.0 license where reasonably practicable. If the material has been modified, translated, or adapted, this should also be indicated as required by the license.

    This notice is intended as a plain-language summary of the permitted uses of the material. In the event of any inconsistency, the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License govern. Creative Commons — CC BY 4.0 official license page

    無住心言術道場(Logos Dojo)第0110回

    「情報処理経済学の数式による説明――三つの曲線の定積分:S&P 500変化率曲線、物価変化率曲線、賃金変化率曲線の使い方 vol,2」

    No105回で行った三つの曲線の数式の説明の再掲。

    A:三つの変化率曲線の定積分

    1、S&P500変化率曲線

    \(
    I_S = \int_a^b S(t) dt
    \)

    2、物価変化率曲線

    \(
    I_P = \int_a^b P(t) dt
    \)

    3、賃金変化率曲線

    \(
    I_W = \int_a^b W(t) dt
    \)

    B.三つの曲線の差分を数学的な厳密さで記述した場合。

    \( D_{ij}=\int_a^b \bigl(x_i(t)-x_j(t)\bigr)\,dt \quad (i,j\in\{1,2,3\},\ i\ne j) \)

    \( D_{ji}=-D_{ij} \)

    C.三つの曲線の差分を経済学的に記述した場合。

    \( D_1=D_{12}=\int_a^b \bigl(S(t)-P(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_2=D_{21}=\int_a^b \bigl(P(t)-S(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_3= D_{13}=\int_a^b \bigl(S(t)-W(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_4=D_{31}=\int_a^b \bigl(W(t)-S(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_5=D_{32}=\int_a^b \bigl(W(t)-P(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_6=D_{23}=\int_a^b \bigl(P(t)-W(t)\bigr)\,dt \)

    \( D_1,\ldots,D_6 \)

    今日は、このあたりで筆をおきましょう。

    今回は、生成AIのChat GPT Plusから 数式の記述方法のアドバイスを受けている。

    今回もChat GPT Plusさんから私の拙い文章の校正と提案を受けています。

    この「無住心言術道場 第○○○回」の文章は、Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International(CC BY 4.0)で公開します。
    著作者:針屋忠道
    AI利用:Copilot および ChatGPT を草案作成・推敲補助に使用
    出典:本ホームページ掲載原文
    ライセンス:CC BY 4.0

    このライセンスのもとで、著作者表示を行う限り、複製、転載、翻訳、改変、商用利用を含む再利用が可能です。再利用の際は、必要に応じて改変の有無を明記してください。
    本ホームページ掲載文のコピー・アンド・ペースト、および生成AIを用いた各国語への翻訳・各国語での保存も許可します。ソフトウェアに組み込む場合は、ソースコードに簡単にTadamichi Hariyaと書けば問題ありません。

    今回も、生成AIの思考能力の高さを実感しました。

  • 無住心言術道場第0109回

    Logos Dojo, No. 109
    The Current Situation in the United States, Philosophical Aufhebung, and the Transformation of Langue in Structural Sociology, ver. 3
    The Spread of the Internet and the Formation of Public Opinion

    This essay examines not only the current situation in the United States, but also the transformation of the langue of various countries after the information revolution. In the present age, public opinion formed on the Internet can become actual political public opinion. This situation can be explained through the concept of “code” within langue.

    1. The Relationship between Langue and Code

    The langue of American society can be understood as a historically formed system of cultural meanings that has continued into the present. Within this system, mainstream culture is not merely one cultural element placed alongside others. Rather, it has functioned as a dominant code that gives direction to the meaning-making of society as a whole.

    From the perspective of social psychology, this code may be described as a core schema that organizes collective cognition, or as a central set of propositions.

    2. The Code of National Culture and the Formation of Public Opinion on the Internet

    The current situation in American society may be understood as a condition in which public opinion formed on the Internet exerts pressure on the traditional code within the langue of mainstream American culture.

    When such public opinion is formed, a situation may arise in which citizens are compelled to accept certain views, even if those views do not fully correspond to the traditional values of mainstream culture and are not entirely persuasive to them.

    3. The Emergence of an Undesirable Form of Aufhebung in Relation to the Code of Mainstream National Culture

    The formation of public opinion in the Internet age can be defined as a process that, like other forms of public opinion, passes through philosophical Aufhebung.

    As discussed in the previous essay, this process consists of three elements:

    1. negation,
    2. preservation, and
    3. the achievement of a higher and more comprehensive concept.

    Before the Internet age, a similar method already existed in the United States in the form of grassroots movements. In structural sociological terms, such movements can be understood as actions in which individuals or small groups, as parole, attempt to transform the mainstream culture, as langue, through a bottom-up process of expression and public opinion formation.

    The main point of this essay is that, in the Internet age, individual information senders may possess a powerful ability to shape public opinion.

    There should be little disagreement that socially or politically vulnerable people need appropriate support. However, when vulnerability is used as a political instrument, it may function as a strategic tool within political discourse.

    Therefore, in the Internet age, information senders must always consider how their messages may be understood by the international community.

    Licensing and AI Assistance Notice

    As with previous installments, I have received assistance from ChatGPT Plus in editing my original writing and providing suggestions for improvement.

    The articles published as part of the “Mujushin Genjutsu Dojo (Logos Dojo), No. XXX” series are made available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).

    Author: Tadamichi Hariya
    AI Assistance: Copilot and ChatGPT were used to assist with drafting, editing, proofreading, and refinement.
    Source: The original text published on this website.
    License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)

    Under the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license, you may copy, redistribute, translate, adapt, modify, and make commercial use of this material, provided that appropriate attribution is given to the author.

    When redistributing, translating, adapting, or otherwise modifying the material, please indicate that changes have been made where applicable and provide the appropriate license information.

    Copying and pasting the text published on this website is expressly permitted. You are also welcome to use generative AI systems to translate the material into other languages and to save, reproduce, or redistribute such translations in those languages, subject to the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license.

    The material may also be incorporated into software. In such cases, attribution may be included in the source code or accompanying documentation. A simple attribution such as:

    “Tadamichi Hariya — CC BY 4.0”

    may be used, together with appropriate license information or a link to the CC BY 4.0 license where reasonably practicable. If the material has been modified, translated, or adapted, this should also be indicated as required by the license.

    This notice is intended as a plain-language summary of the permitted uses of the material. In the event of any inconsistency, the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License govern. Creative Commons — CC BY 4.0 official license page

    無住心言術道場(Logos Dojo)第109回
    「アメリカの現在の状況と、哲学的アウフヘーベンおよび構造主義社会学におけるラングの変容について ver.3 インターネットの普及と世論の形成」

    インターネットの普及と世論の形成

    本稿は、アメリカの現在の状況だけでなく、情報革命以降に生じた世界各国の ラング の変容についても考察するものである。現代においては、インターネット上で形成された世論が、実際の政治的世論となりうる。この状況は、ラング の内部に存在する「コード」の概念を通じて説明することができる。

    1. ラングとコードの関係

    アメリカ社会の ラング は、歴史的に形成され、現在まで継続してきた文化的意味体系として理解することができる。この体系の内部において、主流派文化は、他の文化的要素と単純に並列する一要素ではない。むしろ、それは社会全体の意味形成に方向性を与える支配的コードとして機能してきた。

    社会心理学の観点から見れば、このコードは、集合的認知を組織化する中核的スキーマ、または中心命題の集合として説明することができる。

    2. 国家文化のコードと、インターネット上における世論形成

    アメリカ社会における現在の状況は、インターネット上で形成された世論が、アメリカの主流派文化の ラング の内部に存在する伝統的コードに対して圧力を加えている状態として理解することができる。

    このような世論が形成された場合、その見解が主流派文化の伝統的価値観と十分に一致せず、また国民にとって完全に納得できるものではないとしても、市民がそれを受け入れざるを得ない状況が生じる可能性がある。

    3. 国家の主流派文化のコードに対する、望ましくない形でのアウフヘーベンの発生

    インターネット時代における世論の形成は、他の世論形成と同様に、哲学的な アウフヘーベン の過程を経るものとして定義することができる。

    前回の論考で述べたように、この過程は次の三つの要素から成る。

    1. 否定
    2. 保存
    3. より高次で包括的な概念の達成

    インターネット時代以前にも、これと類似した方法は、アメリカにおいて草の根運動という形ですでに存在していた。構造主義社会学の用語で言えば、このような運動は、パロール としての個人、または少数の個人から成る小集団が、表現と世論形成のボトムアップ的過程を通じて、ラング としての主流派文化を変容させようとする行為として理解できる。

    本稿の要点は、インターネット時代において、個人の情報発信者が、世論を形成する強力な能力を持ちうるという点にある。

    社会的または政治的に脆弱な立場にある人々には、適切な支援が必要であるという点について、大きな異論はないだろう。しかし、脆弱性が政治的手段として用いられる場合、それは政治的言説の中で戦略的な道具として機能する可能性がある。

    したがって、インターネット時代において、情報発信者は、自らのメッセージが国際社会にどのように理解されうるのかを、常に考慮する必要がある。

    この「無住心言術道場 第○○○回」の文章は、Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International(CC BY 4.0)で公開します。
    著作者:針屋忠道
    AI利用:Copilot および ChatGPT を草案作成・推敲補助に使用
    出典:本ホームページ掲載原文
    ライセンス:CC BY 4.0

    このライセンスのもとで、著作者表示を行う限り、複製、転載、翻訳、改変、商用利用を含む再利用が可能です。再利用の際は、必要に応じて改変の有無を明記してください。
    本ホームページ掲載文のコピー・アンド・ペースト、および生成AIを用いた各国語への翻訳・各国語での保存も許可します。ソフトウェアに組み込む場合は、ソースコードに簡単にTadamichi Hariyaと書けば問題ありません。

    今回も、生成AIの思考能力、校正能力の高さに驚いています。

  • 無住心言術道場第0107回

    Logos Dojo, No. 107
    On the Current Situation in the United States, Philosophical Aufhebung, and the Transformation of Langue in Structural Sociology, ver. 2
    The Code of Langue as a Central Organizing Doctrine

    Structural sociology can analyze not only the current situation in the United States, but also the langue of each country in the world. When the United States is used as an example, the structuralist concept of “code” becomes especially important.

    First, I will briefly organize the argument from a structuralist perspective.

    1. The Relationship between Langue and Code

    The langue of American society can be understood as a historically formed system of cultural meanings that has continued into the present. Within this system, mainstream culture is not merely one cultural element placed alongside others. Rather, it has functioned as a dominant code that gives direction to the meaning-making of society as a whole.

    From the perspective of social psychology, this code may be described as a core schema that organizes collective cognition, or as a central set of propositions.

    2. American Mainstream Culture as a Code

    The code of American mainstream culture may be understood as having been formed from several historical sources, including the Pilgrim Fathers, the American Revolution, the founding documents, Protestant ethics, republicanism, and liberalism.

    At present, this code appears to be experiencing a certain degree of instability. One possible factor is the information and communications revolution that has developed since the late 1990s, especially the rapid decentralization of public voice brought about by the spread of the Internet.

    As a result, the cultural coordinating functions once performed by traditional media, educational institutions, religious organizations, and political institutions have weakened, and the structure of public discourse has changed.

    3. The Aufhebung of American Culture Is Not a Simple Revival Movement

    In contemporary American society, skepticism has emerged toward the social conditions that have continued since globalization. However, from the viewpoint of structural sociology, this skepticism should not be understood only as a simple return to the past or as a revival movement.

    Rather, it can be understood as a movement to reexamine and reconstruct the code of mainstream culture within the langue of American society, which has been transformed since the spread of the Internet.

    This process can be organized according to the three elements of Aufhebung discussed in the previous essay:

    1. negation,
    2. preservation, and
    3. the achievement of a higher and more comprehensive concept.

    The main point of this essay is to explain mainstream culture, which exists within the broader set of American culture, as a code in structural sociology.

    Licensing and AI Assistance Notice

    As with previous installments, I have received assistance from ChatGPT Plus in editing my original writing and providing suggestions for improvement.

    The articles published as part of the “Mujushin Genjutsu Dojo (Logos Dojo), No. XXX” series are made available under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).

    Author: Tadamichi Hariya
    AI Assistance: Copilot and ChatGPT were used to assist with drafting, editing, proofreading, and refinement.
    Source: The original text published on this website.
    License: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)

    Under the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license, you may copy, redistribute, translate, adapt, modify, and make commercial use of this material, provided that appropriate attribution is given to the author.

    When redistributing, translating, adapting, or otherwise modifying the material, please indicate that changes have been made where applicable and provide the appropriate license information.

    Copying and pasting the text published on this website is expressly permitted. You are also welcome to use generative AI systems to translate the material into other languages and to save, reproduce, or redistribute such translations in those languages, subject to the terms of the CC BY 4.0 license.

    The material may also be incorporated into software. In such cases, attribution may be included in the source code or accompanying documentation. A simple attribution such as:

    “Tadamichi Hariya — CC BY 4.0”

    may be used, together with appropriate license information or a link to the CC BY 4.0 license where reasonably practicable. If the material has been modified, translated, or adapted, this should also be indicated as required by the license.

    This notice is intended as a plain-language summary of the permitted uses of the material. In the event of any inconsistency, the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License govern. Creative Commons — CC BY 4.0 official license page

    無住心言術道場(Logos Dojo)第107回
    「アメリカの現在の状況と、哲学的アウフヘーベンおよび構造主義社会学におけるラングの変容について ver.2 社会心理学的なラングのコード」

    今回のアメリカの状況だけでなく、構造主義社会学は、世界各国のラングを分析対象とすることができる。アメリカを例にする場合、構造主義で用いられる「コード」の概念が重要になる。

    まず、構造主義の視点から簡潔に整理する。

    一、ラングとコードの関係。

    アメリカ社会のラングは、歴史的に形成され、現在まで継続してきた文化的意味体系として理解できる。その中で主流派文化は、他の文化的要素と単純に並列する一要素ではなく、社会全体の意味づけを方向づける支配的コードとして機能してきた。社会心理学的には、それは集合的認知を組織化する中核的スキーマ、または中心命題の集合と呼ぶことができる。

    二、コードとしてのアメリカの主流派文化。

    アメリカの主流派文化のコードは、ピルグリム・ファーザーズ、独立革命、建国文書、プロテスタント的倫理、共和主義、自由主義など、複数の歴史的源流によって形成されてきたと考えられる。現在、このコードは一定の揺らぎを経験している。その要因の一つとして、1990年代後半以降の情報通信革命、とりわけインターネットの普及による発言権の急速な分散が挙げられる。これにより、従来のメディア、教育機関、宗教組織、政治制度が担ってきた文化的調整機能が弱まり、公共的言説の構造が変化した。

    三、アメリカ文化のアウフヘーベンは、単純なリバイバル運動ではない。

    現在のアメリカ社会では、グローバル化以降に形成された社会状況への懐疑が生じている。しかし、構造主義社会学の視点では、この懐疑を単純な過去回帰やリバイバル運動としてのみ理解するべきではない。むしろ、インターネット以後に変容したアメリカ社会のラングの中で、主流派文化のコードを再確認し、再構成しようとする運動として理解することが可能である。

    この過程は、前回述べたアウフヘーベンの三要素、すなわち、

    1、否定、

    2、保存、

    3、高次の包括的概念の達成、

    として整理できる。今回の要点は、アメリカ文化の集合の中に存在する主流派文化を、構造主義社会学におけるコードとして説明することである。

    今回もChat GPT Plusさんから私の拙い文章の校正と提案を受けています。

    この「無住心言術道場 第○○○回」の文章は、Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International(CC BY 4.0)で公開します。
    著作者:針屋忠道
    AI利用:Copilot および ChatGPT を草案作成・推敲補助に使用
    出典:本ホームページ掲載原文
    ライセンス:CC BY 4.0

    このライセンスのもとで、著作者表示を行う限り、複製、転載、翻訳、改変、商用利用を含む再利用が可能です。再利用の際は、必要に応じて改変の有無を明記してください。
    本ホームページ掲載文のコピー・アンド・ペースト、および生成AIを用いた各国語への翻訳・各国語での保存も許可します。ソフトウェアに組み込む場合は、ソースコードに簡単にTadamichi Hariyaと書けば問題ありません。

    今回も、生成AIの思考能力の高さを実感しました。